Skip to content

Biting my tongue until it damn near bleeds

As some of you know, I recently deleted my entire blog. I had several reasons (of which this episode was less an immediate trigger than it was the icing on the hyper-rhetorical cake), but the bottom line was that my life had been overtaken by (overt) political blogging, such that most other subjects and activities had become subordinate.

There was also a growing disgust with the state of political discourse within the feminist blogosphere. Many of the feminist blogs to which I had once looked for nuanced explorations of crucial issues of politics and culture were now doing little besides spewing constant streams of grossly distorting invective against Barack Obama (or what they would oh-so-innocently refer to as “vetting the candidate”).

When I took a deeply felt, authentically diplomatic approach, my would-be sisters advocating for Hillary Clinton generally ignored me (with precious few exceptions – you know who you are). And when I took more of a fighting approach, I began to deplore the sound of my own voice.

Finally, I did a post specifically on the dangers of the Obama/Clinton divide among progressives (using a one-shot opportunity to guest blog at Huffington Post), and while responses were generally favorable (I was thanked, for instance, for “inserting a little sanity into the divisive discourse”), it was also clear that my words could not begin to counteract what was, after all, a tsunami-sized wave of grossly cynical, and sometimes openly hateful discourse.

So, does my about-face with regard to overt political blogging mean I no longer care – passionately – about these issues? Hardly. (Indeed, what woke me up in the middle of the night, provoking me to write this, was a dream containing the audaciously brassy and insistent chorus line from Skunk Anansie’s Yes It’s Fucking Political.) Well then, does it mean my support for Barack Obama’s candidacy is in any way lessened? Most certainly not.

But if months engaging in what had been a labor of love – writing about the issues in this election – have gotten me absolutely nowhere in terms of fostering open, substantive dialogue with progressives’ common interests in mind, why on earth would I continue with that labor now? (For while it is my candidate’s prerogative – and, indeed, mandate – to respond as needed1 to constant attacks coming from the Clinton camp, I don’t see that my doing so adds to the current discourse.)

Today, as Pennsylvania voters go to the polls, I’m going to impose a total news blackout in this household (from TV to newspapers to blogs to Twitter) until I know most of the returns are in, and my kids are in bed. Because, in the event Clinton’s last-ditch effort to save her campaign, by deploying that most Rovian of all despicably Rovian tactics – using the image of Osama bin Laden in campaign ads, in an effort to scare voters (remember when Democrats were in universal opposition to this practice?) – is successful (where ‘success’ would mean more than a marginal victory in this particular state, with significant net gain in pledged delegates), I am going to be incredibly angry. And I’d rather my kids didn’t see me like that.

Whatever the outcome, this time tomorrow, I’ll compose myself again, and deal with whatever comes next. If, somehow, Clinton becomes the Democratic party’s nominee, I will certainly vote for her, because McCain is by far the more dangerous candidate.

In the Huffington Post guest blog entry referenced above, I included in a footnote this somewhat out-of-place comment: Each post I write on the election, I die a little. Extricating myself from these debates, then – despite a constant stream of outrages to which I might otherwise have been compelled to react – has been in the interests of self-preservation, and I don’t regret it.

Going back to something I jokingly said on Twitter, awhile back:

Feminist blogosphere, I wish I knew how to quit you.

I’m happy to say that with this last post, I finally have.

Good luck, Pennsylvania. I hope you’ll vote your conscience.

__

1 As Obama said, in an interview to be aired in full on the Today Show later this morning:

This is an old trick, right? Somebody attacks you and attacks you and attacks you, and when you finally call them on it, suddenly you’re ‘engaging in the same tactics.’ We have been extraordinarily restrained during the course of this campaign and have generally responded only to attacks that have already been leveled at us by Senator Clinton.

  • v
    i hope you dont mind if i dont quit you.

    hoping you and yours are all good
    xxx
  • Backatcha, babe.
  • It's so hard not to get wrapped up in it all. I take lots of deep breaths and click away, but man it's hard not to fall in head first.
  • I've actually had to ban myself from certain blogs for the duration. Once the nomination is wrapped up, I'm make some cautious trips back to see if my eyes don't again start to burn instantly upon contact with some of my formerly favorite sites.
  • I'm trying not to go into the Obamabot type arguments, but in one post I did point out two different times when I was told I was being dumb or 'over sensitive' for call people out on ablist and sexist remarks. *sigh* I try to always make sure that people know that I am not painting everyone with a huge brush, since there are people like you (not the majority of people my posts attract ha ha).

    But I love you, and you know that. *mwah*
  • I love ya back, and I do know that - thank you, you have no idea what a difference it has made.
  • Brave Musketeer
    Unfortunately, I have experienced the same thing. It is really saddening because I can understand some of the pain and anger. Hillary has been treated unfairly by the media and this is a terrible way to treat women candidates. But what I have seen is not simply a critique of this sexism but gross bias, ignoring or engaging in racism, and willful twisting of Obama's words while giving Hillary a pass on the very same topics. I am voting for Barack because of his strong bipartisan message and because I am an idealist who believes in changing bad politics instead of playing by them. But I still respect Hillary. But what I experience online with feminist blogging is not the usual insights and higher focus that I know are usually about. What I see is the same kind of arguments that marginalize us all. I have gotten to the point where I cannot read but a few articles, just enough to keep up with what is current in this race because if I delve in, I feel like I am trying to push a wall down. This has been a large disappointment for me to see in the feminist community and the democratic party. I honestly wonder where we will be when the dust is settled and we look back on what we said and did. Will there be apologies and insight or will we be further divided?
  • Hey there, Brave Musketeer. Since I've disabled sitemeter I have no idea how you found me, but I love you already. And would have said so a whole week ago when you comment came in (same to the ever-awesome Maria Niles above), but I've just been overwhelmed. Suffice it to say, you have spoken my own mind here. Thank you.

    (And re: "will there be apologies"? I certainly hope so - all around.)
  • Thanks for this post. You've laid out a lot of the feelings I've been having and actions I've taken really well. I'm not actively involved in the feminist blogosphere and yet I've still been shocked at the alienating and exclusionary arguments that are being made by feminists. I can't imagine how an Obama supporter could continue to engage without it becoming dangerously toxic. I am also deeply disturbed by the number of feminists who say they will vote for McCain when Obama is the nominee. I can only hope that there is collective amnesia and that they will not actually engage in that dangerous hypocrisy.
  • Maria - I regret it's taken me this long to reply to your comment, but as you may know, I've had a few things going on. That said? Even while the focus of your activism and writing hasn't been exclusively around feminism, I still regard you as one of the most kick-ass feminists I've come across in some time. Your piece at Blogher for Women's History Month? Absolutely rocked. (And sorry it's taken me this long to say so.)

    And I very much share the specific hope you've articulated here.
blog comments powered by Disqus